In the latest issue:

In Quarantine

Erin Maglaque

Après Brexit

Ferdinand Mount

Short Cuts: Springtime for Donald

David Bromwich

Meetings with their Gods

Claire Hall

‘Generation Left’

William Davies

At the North Miami Museum: Alice Paalen Rahon

Mary Ann Caws

Buchan’s Banter

Christopher Tayler

‘American Dirt’

Christian Lorentzen

Fiction and the Age of Lies

Colin Burrow

In Lahore

Tariq Ali

GOD HATES YOUR FEELINGS

James Lasdun

Rereading Bowen

Tessa Hadley

At the Corner House

Rosemary Hill

William Gibson

Thomas Jones

Poem: ‘Murph & Me’

August Kleinzahler

The Stud File

Kevin Brazil

John Boorman’s Quiet Ending

David Thomson

In Shanghai: The West Bund Museum

John-Paul Stonard

Diary: The Deborah Orr I Knew

Jenny Turner

The Word from Wuhan

Wang Xiuying

At the Towner GalleryBrian Dillon
Close
Close
Vol. 41 No. 7 · 4 April 2019
At the Towner Gallery

Carey Young, Palais de Justice

Brian Dillon

1299 words

The Palais de Justice​ in Brussels is a product of civic and architectural delirium, a Circumlocution Office looming over the historically working-class Marolles district like a sinister, secular basilica. It’s bigger than St Peter’s in Rome, covering an area of 26,000 square metres, with reputedly the largest accumulation of stone blocks in Europe. Its architect, Joseph Poelaert, inspired by John Martin’s scenes of apocalyptic ruin, had been fantasising about such a structure for years before he won the commission to design the new Palais in 1861. Time passed, costs swelled from four million to fifty million francs, Poelaert died in 1879 and four years later the city received its monumental hilltop labyrinth – ‘a colossus, inside a monster’, Paul Verlaine said. Public reaction was hostile. The building was considered an affront to Brussels – a hypertrophied analogue of Belgium’s imperial ambitions – and on the day it opened a mob invaded, tearing down statues and paintings, pissing and shitting on the marble floors.

From the start, the courtrooms, corridors and precincts of the Palais de Justice seemed also to constitute a ruinous, fantastical museum of the building itself. Its scale, and awful mix of Egyptian, Greek and Byzantine influences, recalls the architectural reveries of Piranesi; it is said that there are staircases that go nowhere, like those in his Carceri d’Invenzione. When Freud saw it two years after it was completed, he was put in mind of an Assyrian palace as drawn by Gustave Doré. Later visitors have hardly got past the bristling columns at the main entrance before thinking of Kafka: this is where Orson Welles hoped to film his adaptation of The Trial. W.G. Sebald’s Jacques Austerlitz goes wandering in the depths of the Palais looking for Masonic symbols, and finds corridors piled high with ancient office furniture, chairs and lecterns and roll-top cupboards – as if the last, lost inhabitants had barricaded themselves in.

When the artist Carey Young first began exploring the Palais, she was struck by the female judges and lawyers. She spotted five women in conference in a courtroom; they spotted her, and rushed to close the door. Young’s 18-minute video Palais de Justice, which is on show at the Towner Art Gallery in Eastbourne (until 2 June), is a meditation on authority and visibility. After her request to film in the building was denied on security grounds – a magistrate and her clerk were murdered in court in 2010 – Young decided to work surreptitiously, with the help of an assistant, a small tripod and long lenses. A Belgian lawyer advised her, if caught pointing her camera into courtrooms, to say that judges are public figures and possess no right to privacy while at the bench. The argument worked on the few security guards who tried to stop her.

Palais de Justice is projected to fill a large gallery wall at the Towner and at first it seems the work will address itself to the wild iconography and maddening dimensions of the place. A young man in T-shirt and trainers descends a monumental set of stairs, flanked by huge statues of classical orators. (Tourists often don’t progress beyond this Cecil B. DeMille scenery, exhausting themselves trying to photograph its bizarre angles and vistas.) Next we’re looking down vertiginously into the vast, gloomy lobby, or salle des pas perdus, where lawyers meet with their clients in plush alcoves. A distant porter toils across the hall, pushing a trolley full of papers. A small party of lawyers trots by laden down with overstuffed folders, like something out of a cartoon by Daumier. But Young quickly takes us past this bureaucratic comedy, into the heart of the legal process and its delicate performance.

The courtrooms of the Palais de Justice have heavy doors padded with leather and inset with round windows, and it’s through these that much of Young’s video was secretly shot. She concentrates at first on the faces and gestures of the judges – they shuffle their papers, pause with pen in midair, peer over their reading glasses at the advocates in front of them, cock their heads quizzically or stare straight ahead with what looks like unfathomable boredom but is probably strategic impassivity. They are all silent. Stuck on the other side of soundproof doors, Young gives Palais de Justice a soundtrack drawn from the muffled life of the corridor, which occasionally we see reflected in the scratched pane of a courtroom porthole.

The judges dominate much of Palais de Justice, but they slowly give way to portraits of younger women, the lawyers arguing before them. One woman appears early on, perfectly framed in profile by the little window: she looks like a study, in miniature, of rhetorical gestures, attitudes of appeal or even supplication. Her colleagues, who come later, are more fragmented – whether by the limited camera angles available to Young or her deliberate editing out of their faces. The young advocates are reduced to anonymous details: an ear, the nape of a neck, hair that rhymes with the tight pleats and loose folds of their robes. In these shots, Young’s long lens produces a tiny depth of field, sharply isolating aspects of person and dress from the blurred suggestion of courtroom panelling, distant paintings and other faceless figures. It’s as if a different gaze has intruded, voyeuristic and fixated and very likely male.

It’s the gaze, most obviously, of some cinematic precursors. All those backs of heads, with hair pinned up or loosely pulled to one side of the neck, resemble certain indelible shots in Andrei Tarkovsky’s Solaris, Chris Marker’s La Jetée and its ur-text, Hitchcock’s Vertigo. There’s a sci-fi quality to Palais de Justice: from the submarine portholes to the growing sense that the work shows a future in which women have taken over the institutions of justice, and perhaps much else (assuming, that is, anything exists outside of this huge self-involved system). The men who appear in Young’s video seem at best peripheral figures, always subject to the speech and gaze of the judges, or stranded in passageways and vestibules. One fretful advocate looks as though he has been waiting there for ever.

Young has been making art about the law for some years, and in a variety of media. Report of the Legal Subcommittee (2010) is a print of an astronomical map, accompanied by the transcript of a UN meeting to determine the legal definition of outer space. Legal Maxims (2013) consists of the phrases ‘wrong in itself’ and ‘nobody’s thing’ rendered in white neon, as if the principles of malum in se and res nullius have been translated into the rhetorical register of street advertising. Her work is frequently exercised by the language of the law, its precision, abstraction, density.

Palais de Justice comes at the subject from another direction and in a more aesthetic mood. Young has made, but not shown at the Towner, a related series of eight photographs entitled, after Kafka, Before the Law, which depicts more or less ornate courtroom doors – closed, ajar or wide open – suggesting different degrees of procedural transparency or opacity. Verlaine wrote that the Palais de Justice ‘wants to be as terrible as the Law, severe and sumptuously naked’. In Young’s video a luxurious austerity prevails, in the architecture and among her human subjects. The viewer watches them covertly but here and there a heart-stopping moment of connection seems to occur. A judge’s gaze drifts or darts towards the camera. The waiting male lawyer turns and gives the artist (and us) a hard stare. Except it’s an illusion: Young was too far away, or too well concealed, to be observed. Both she and the law are getting on with their hard work, secretly and in plain sight.

Send Letters To:

The Editor
London Review of Books,
28 Little Russell Street
London, WC1A 2HN

letters@lrb.co.uk

Please include name, address, and a telephone number.

Letters

Vol. 41 No. 9 · 9 May 2019

Brian Dillon’s review of Carey Young’s video Palais de Justice reminded me of my visits to the building some years ago, when giving English courses to Belgian magistrates (LRB, 4 April). I was told that the lower courts were on the lower floors, while the Cour de Cassation/Hof van Cassatie (Supreme Court) was under the building’s cupola. Rumours abounded concerning the building (on which the scaffolding for long-delayed restoration work had been in place for so many years it was in need of restoration itself): the legend of a homeless man living in a never visited storeroom for years on end, or the local who so hated the building he regularly smeared it with corrosive paste in the hope that it would eventually come crashing down. An entire city block had been erased to clear the site, and the name of its architect, Poelaert, was accursed for generations in the eyes of the populace. Even in today’s Brussels, if you really want to insult somebody, you need only call them a skieven (‘crooked’) architect.

Richard Tagart
Haywards Heath, West Sussex

send letters to

The Editor
London Review of Books
28 Little Russell Street
London, WC1A 2HN

letters@lrb.co.uk

Please include name, address and a telephone number

Read anywhere with the London Review of Books app, available now from the App Store for Apple devices, Google Play for Android devices and Amazon for your Kindle Fire.

Read More

Sign up to our newsletter

For highlights from the latest issue, our archive and the blog, as well as news, events and exclusive promotions.

Newsletter Preferences