Popper’s World
John Maynard Smith, 18 August 1983
The Open Universe: An Argument for Indeterminism
by Karl Popper, edited by W.W. Bartley.
Hutchinson, 185 pp., £15, July 1982,0 09 146180 4 Show More
by Karl Popper, edited by W.W. Bartley.
Hutchinson, 185 pp., £15, July 1982,
“... Karl Popper is perhaps the only living philosopher of science who has had a substantial influence on the way scientists do what they do. I say ‘perhaps’ because the same claim might be made for Thomas Kuhn. However, Kuhn seems to me a perceptive sociologist of science, but a poor philosopher. Also, in so far as he has had an effect on the way scientists behave, it has been pernicious: to be a great scientist, according to Kuhn, you must do revolutionary science, and the best evidence that you are doing it is that you are so obscure and inconsistent in your statements as to be wholly incomprehensible to others ... ”