Can there be such a thing as music criticism?
John Deathridge, 20 February 1986
Music and Civilisation: Essays in Honour of Paul Henry Lang
edited by Edmond Strainchamps, Maria Rika Maniates and Christopher Hatch.
Norton, 499 pp., £35, March 1985,0 393 01677 3 Show More
edited by Edmond Strainchamps, Maria Rika Maniates and Christopher Hatch.
Norton, 499 pp., £35, March 1985,
The Farthest North of Humanness: Letters of Percy Grainger 1901-1914
edited by Kay Dreyfus.
Macmillan, 542 pp., £25, December 1985,0 333 38085 1 Show More
edited by Kay Dreyfus.
Macmillan, 542 pp., £25, December 1985,
“... from other disciplines. But a dissection of The Rite of Spring adapting from linguistics, say, John Lyon’s version of the theory of semantic structure, or a semiotic analysis of Grainger’s Handel in the Strand are liable to end up, too, as involved technical explanations communicating less real critical insight than the trenchant views of Taruskin and ... ”