Images of the Occupation
The Editors
Uri Avnery on 'the face of a boy':
It is not yet clear which are more effective in the long run: the bullets or the photos.
A test case is a short clip taken recently in a remote West Bank village called al-Nabi Saleh.
Every Israeli has seen this footage many times by now. It has been shown again and again by all Israeli TV stations. Many millions around the world have seen it on their local TV. It is making the rounds in the social media.
The clip shows an incident that occurred near the village on Friday, two weeks ago. Nothing very special. Nothing terrible. Just a routine event. But the pictures are unforgettable.
You can read the whole piece here, and watch the video here.
Comments
No, Uri, the Palestinians shoot Israelis.
Between 2001 and 2014, Palestinian terrorists fired 19,000 rockets at Israel's civilian population. In addition, for the 2001-2011 period (before Operation Cast Lead), according to Hamas's own scorecard, the following attacks were carried out:
•4303 terror attacks
•61 suicide attacks
•24 attempts to capture Israelis
•423 bombings
•90 sniper attacks
•146 ambushes
These included:
*The massacre at the Mercaz Harav yeshiva killing 8 students
*No. 32A bus, mainly carrying Israeli schoolchildren, Patt junction, Jerusalem 19 dead, 70 injured
*Sbarro Pizzeria, Jerusalem
15 dead, 130 injured
*Snooker club, Rishon Letzion
15 dead, 55 injured
*Student cafeteria, Hebrew University , Jerusalem
10 dead, 85 injured
*Park Hotel Passover meal, Netanya
30 dead, 140 injured
In all, around 1,250 Israelis have been murdered in terrorist attacks since 2000.
That is why there is a blockade in Gaza and that is why there are security roads, security fences, checkposts and arrests in the West Bank. Rocks too have killed Israelis and caused grievous injuries. Whoever throws rocks will be arrested, no matter how it looks on television. If the Palestinians wish to see the occupation end, they will have to repudiate terrorism and reconcile themselves to the existence of a sovereign non-Muslim state in the Middle East.
As far as negotiations are concerned, the contours of a settlement are understood by everyone. It is Abu Mazen who has refused to reopen negotiations, and it is questionable, given the strength of Hamas on the West Bamk, if he can deliver a peace agreement. Admittedly, Israel has great misgivings about the process at the present time. Under no circumstances will a situation be allowed to arise where Hamas can set up its rocket launchers 15 yards from Jewish Jerusalem.
I can see that Hamas's terrorist attacks have made no impression on you.
Israel's repression of the first intifada,
And the origins of the first intifada?
Let's get one thing straight, Fred, Hamas, no matter how sdious, is a resistance movement.
Before the resistance movements came what?
It helps to dig a little further than the hasbara spreadsheet.
Before the "resistance movements" came the Six-Day War. I was in Jerusalem on June 5, 1967, and experienced Hussein's unprovoked and indiscriminate bombardment of the Jewish city. Where were you? In Sheboygan? In Timbuktu? Fast asleep? Digging? You start a war, you lose a war, you get your territory occupied. That's the oldest story in history.
I doubt if you have any firt-hand knowledge of the nature of the Israeli occupation, other than the horror stories you read in biased second- and third-hand English-language sources and are unequipped to verify or evaluate. I served on active reserve duty in the Israeli army for nearly 20 years and can say that with the exception of very occasional instances of misconduct on the part of individuals, all Israeli security measures are exclusively and legitimately aimed at preventing terrorist acts.
Every single former Israeli reservist or conscript that I've ever met recounted the ubiquitous and quotidian horror of the job - casual brutalities visited on Palestinians. Hmmm... I imagine you rather enjoyed your work.
I somehow doubt that, unless you have met very few or move in extreme left wing circles where Israeli reservists magically turn up to berate Israel. I have certainly talked to a few more Israelis than you have and I have furthermore actually lived the experience of the occupation, which very few Israelis would define as a "horror" or in terms of casual brutality unless it suited his political ideology, though no one likes to do reserve duty for reasons that may be hidden from people like yourself who have never served in an army. It would be wiser on your part not to make categorical statements about what you are unequipped to verify.